BBC iPlayer changes mean a degraded experience on Windows 10 Mobile

Published by at

BBC iPlayer has been quite useable in Edge (and other browsers) under Windows 10 Mobile for the last three years, since the dropping of support to Windows Phone 8.1 in 2015. OK, so DRM-ed downloads weren't possible, but you could still stream videos seamlessly. With a change last week to its streams - and with no sign of Windows 10 Mobile or Edge in its compatibility page - the watching experience just took a step backwards. Programmes now play in a smaller, offset window. And it's clearly not intentional, since the rest of the UI uses the whole screen. Sigh.

ScreenshotScreenshot

iPlayer is on the BBC's web site and trivial to find. And looks good at first. Here I'm browsing the thousands of programmes...

ScreenshotScreenshot

So I pick a programme and (in this case, on a freshly reset phone) sign into my (free BBC account)...

Screenshot

And playback then starts, but in a window roughly 75% the size of the UI. This is with the 'full-screen' icon tapped, obviously. The UI elements disappear after a few seconds, I only show them here for clarity, but you don't get a true full-screen watching experience. Which is odd, as you did prior to last week's server-side changes.

ScreenshotScreenshot

Let's try another programme. In fact, heck, let's try another browser, in this case Monument Browser, and let's set the emulation to be 'Android', since it all works fine on Android phones....

Screenshot

No dice. Something about the Windows 10 Mobile built-in MP4 video playing code is not playing well with the BBC's servers, it seems. 

This has been tested on multiple Windows 10 Mobile phones, so it's platform-wise. Fairly obviously, it's an incompatibility between the iPlayer site code and Windows 10 Mobile's Edge build, and wasn't picked up in testing because no one at the BBC is still testing its site against even the last Lumias to be made. All a bit dispiriting. On the plus side, you can still watch the BBC's programmes and streaming does start quite quickly. But it's frustrating to have so much screen real estate not used for the actual content.

Do please let me know if this affects other platforms and if something gets fixed at the BBC's end. Comments welcome.