Review: Connected Devices UWP
I have to wonder why it's taking Microsoft so long to implement its much anticipated 'cloud clipboard' - but then I review something like Connected Devices and the complexities start to hit home. You may remember that I've already reviewed Hand Off UWP, from a different developer, which had everything but clipboard operations sorted. Clipboard copying here mostly works, plus you get local file sharing, which turns out to work well too, and Connected Devices is absolutely free. What's not to love?
What sounds simple (clipboard copying via the cloud and your 'connected' [and signed in] devices) is actually quite complicated. For example, if you're signed into two phones, a tablet and a couple of PCs, would you really want the copied content in the paste buffer on all of these? What if it's something inappropriate or sensitive? What if the content is of a type that's not compatible, not least because you might paste it into the wrong application or situation? What if the copied item is large and bandwidth is an issue on some cellular devices?
And so on. It's not an easy computer science problem to solve. Which is why Connected Devices here goes down the tightly focussed route of picking the particular device you want to target and even then restricting you to either a string of plain text or specific attachment types, the latter only when both 'ends' are deemed compatible and hooked up on the same network.
From the Store description:
With this app, you can share any web link, text, or file from any app to any other Windows 10 Anniversary device that you own. This incudes: Windows 10 desktops, laptops, tablets, phones, Xbox One, and Hololens.
- Share text instantly to your Windows 10 or Windows 10 mobile devices and have it automatically copied to the target device's clipboard
- Share urls instantly to any of your Windows 10 devices and have them automatically open in the target device's default browser
- Share youtube videos instantly to any of your Windows 10 devices have them automatically open in your favorite youtube apps like myTube and TubeCast
- Share a single file or multiple files at once to your Windows 10 or Windows 10 mobile devices over local wireless or wired networks that are not blocked by firewalls
All of which overblows the functionality slightly, and even more so when you realise that there's quite a bit of uncertainty involved - which the app does warn you about as you go along, in fairness.
I've been trying out Connected Devices between a Lumia 950 and a Surface Pro. Let's start with the simplest case, copying a text string - in this case a URL - from Surface Pro to Lumia:
At first sight, there's no way to copy more than a single 'line' of text by this mechanism, but there's a hack, whereby you can paste multiple paragraphs of text into the send line and then paste it all back out at the other end - the catch is that the text isn't shown by either end's Connected Devices app - you discover that it worked by using the text in another application!
You can send attachments too, here's me tapping the paper clip icon and then picking a high res wallpaper to send over:
What about going in the other direction, from phone to Desktop? Let's try and send a photo:
One nice touch is that if you try and copy something to a locally connected compatible phone and this doesn't already have the Connected Devices application installed then the latter device is taken straight to the entry in the Store, ready to install it after all. Very neat.
I'm only scratching the surface of the possible permutations of device and content, but you get the idea. You'll also get the idea that it's not foolproof - more than once nothing appeared to happen at all. There are several tech ducks which all have to be in a row for this to work as advertised. Mind you, this application is free, so it's churlish to complain too much - and the developer does seem to be very active in terms of fixes, so it's worth being patient. And maybe it'll solve a problem for you and your own workflow?
Overall, though, you have to ask yourself the question "wouldn't it be ten times quicker and easier to just email the text or attachment to yourself and pick it up on the other device?" Or, for files and attachments, "why not just put them in OneDrive and grab them as needed from there?" Bombproof, independent on both devices being fully active and powered on, etc. Mind you, when dealing with anything other than pure text, Connected Devices seems to piggyback on the local Wifi network and so uses drastically less cloud bandwidth - so there's a big saving there compared to the pure cloud solution.
Connected Devices, as with Hand Off previously, is an interesting concept application and great practice for the developer but it is unlikely to solve many real world inter-device needs. If it worked 100% of the time then maybe it would find a niche. But the current 90% doesn't quite cut it, even as a free application.
Reviewed by Steve Litchfield at